OEM windshield or MS batwing?

Hi guy's, new to the forum and just got a new 09 13 non tourer. The first thing I want to add is a windshield. For about the same money I can get the oem shield w/mounting brackets and Hd lowers, or the MS batwing w/mounting brackets,shield,wind deflectors. I understand the batwing still needs lowers to help with buffeting, but I'm not crazy about using the MS lowers with those clamps on the fork covers. Is there a way to use either bucks or HD lowers with the BW? The bike is black so I think the BW would look nice but wondering how well the mounting system works and if the BW moves around alot at speed. Your opinions on which way to go are much appreciated as I only want to buy this stuff once.