Yamaha 1300 Tourer - Yamaha 1300 Tourer Fansite

Has anyone tried both the Yamaha OEM "Lower Wind Deflectors" AND the Harley chrome ones?

I have the Harley ones and they work GREAT and look OK, but mine have gotten bent and I'm interested in trying something different AS LONG AS IT WILL BE EFFECTIVE.

I thought I had read a post where someone has started with Bucks, gone to Harley (and found those better), and then gone to OEM and found those to be the best of all.